Home › Business Search › Ohio › Columbus › Insurance Agency

Best Insurance Agencies in Columbus, Ohio

6 businesses
Filters
Business type
Location
6 listings
Clear all
Ohio×Columbus×Insurance Agency×Clear All

Rankings use the published BizScore formulas. How we score

6Insurance Agencies scored in Columbus
55Average BizScore
66Top BizScore
33%AI Visibility 50 or higher
71Average SEO score
4.0Average Google rating (5 rated)

Top Insurance Agencies in Columbus

Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business

Showing 1-6 of 6 Insurance Agencies listings in Columbus, OH · page 1 of 1

#1Tracy Insurance Agency

3.3 Google rating

Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Tracy Insurance Agency website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility58
SEO79
  • Insurance Agency
  • Columbus, Ohio
  • 6145454500
  • tracyinsuranceagency.com

Tracy Insurance Agency is an insurance agency in Columbus, Ohio. The agency provides a wide range of coverage options for individuals and businesses throughout all of Ohio, specializing in car, home, business, commercial, life, and contractors insurance...

Ranked #1 of 9 Insurance Agency listings in ColumbusScores updated Jun 7, 2026
Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Progressive Insurance - Claims Office of Columbus website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility53
SEO69
  • Insurance Agency
  • Columbus, Ohio
  • 6149043140
  • progressive.com

Progressive Insurance - Claims Office of Columbus is an Insurance Agency in Columbus, OH. As a claims office for Progressive, it handles the processing and reporting of insurance claims for various product lines. The agency serves customers filing claims for...

Ranked #4 of 9 Insurance Agency listings in ColumbusScores updated Jun 10, 2026

#3Insurance Agency of Ohio

4.9 Google rating

Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
I

Score breakdown

AI Visibility47
SEO75
  • Insurance Agency
  • Columbus, Ohio
  • 3804008823
  • iaofohio.com

Insurance Agency of Ohio is an insurance agency in Columbus, OH. It provides personal, business, life, and industry specialty insurance to residents and businesses throughout Central Ohio, including Worthington and Franklin County. The family-owned agency...

Ranked #5 of 9 Insurance Agency listings in ColumbusScores updated Jun 16, 2026

#4Dan Coonfare Agency LLC

4.7 Google rating

Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Dan Coonfare Agency LLC website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility35
SEO69
  • Insurance Agency
  • Columbus, Ohio
  • 6144865400
  • coonfareinsurance.com

Dan Coonfare Agency LLC is an insurance agency in Columbus, Ohio. The agency provides a wide range of coverage options for individuals and businesses, including auto, home, life, and health insurance. Their specialized services extend to protecting various...

Ranked #8 of 9 Insurance Agency listings in ColumbusScores updated Jun 10, 2026
Visit WebsiteView ListingClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
QuickInsured (An Acrisure Company) website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility37
SEO71
  • Insurance Agency
  • Columbus, Ohio
  • acrisure.com

QuickInsured (An Acrisure Company) is a licensed insurance agency in Columbus, Ohio, specializing in personalized homeowners insurance solutions for individuals and families. The agency helps clients find tailored coverage to protect their homes and personal...

Ranked #7 of 9 Insurance Agency listings in ColumbusScores updated Jun 7, 2026

#6Encova Insurance

3.9 Google rating

Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Encova Insurance website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility19
SEO60
  • Insurance Agency
  • Columbus, Ohio
  • 8443626821
  • encova.com

Encova Insurance is an Insurance Agency in Columbus, OH, located at 471 E Broad St. It holds a rating of 3.90 based on 0 reviews. Encova Insurance offers comprehensive product offerings for home, auto, and business insurance, as well as workers' compensation...

Ranked #9 of 9 Insurance Agency listings in ColumbusScores updated Jun 7, 2026
Is this your business? Claim your free listing →

BizScoreAI ranks 6 insurance agencies in Columbus, Ohio by BizScore, a measured composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, local citations, local search pages and profile completeness. Rankings come from the scores, never from paid placement. Open any profile for its full breakdown, and claim your free listing if it is your business.

Frequently Asked Questions

How are insurance agencies in Columbus ranked on BizScoreAI?

By BizScore, a measured composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, local citations, local search pages and profile completeness. No listing pays for position; the formulas are published on the How We Score page.

How many insurance agencies in Columbus, Ohio does BizScoreAI track?

6 insurance agencies in Columbus currently meet the profile-quality bar for this page, with an average BizScore of 55 and a top score of 66.

What does AI Visibility mean for a insurance agency?

It measures whether AI assistants and AI-powered search can find, read and cite the business's website: structured data, crawlability, clear entity information and content that answers questions. 33% of measured insurance agencies in Columbus score 50 or higher.

Is being listed free?

Yes. Every insurance agency in Columbus is listed and scored for free, and claiming a listing is free too.