Home › Business Search › Indiana › Indianapolis › Insurance Agency

Best Insurance Agencies in Indianapolis, Indiana

9 businesses
Filters
Business type
Location
9 listings
Clear all
Indiana×Indianapolis×Insurance Agency×Clear All

Rankings use the published BizScore formulas. How we score

9Insurance Agencies scored in Indianapolis
57Average BizScore
69Top BizScore
22%AI Visibility 50 or higher
74Average SEO score
4.8Average Google rating (6 rated)

Top Insurance Agencies in Indianapolis

Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business

Showing 1-9 of 9 Insurance Agencies listings in Indianapolis, IN · page 1 of 1

#1The George Group

4.4 Google rating · 11 reviews

Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
The George Group website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility57
SEO89
  • Insurance Agency
  • Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 3178622200
  • thegeorgegroupagency.com

The George Group is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN. It offers a full range of personal and commercial coverage, including auto, homeowners, renters, motorcycle, boat and marine policies, as well as business owners packages, commercial auto...

Ranked #2 of 13 Insurance Agency listings in IndianapolisScores updated Jun 10, 2026
Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Capitol Insurance & Risk Management Group website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility65
SEO75
  • Insurance Agency
  • Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 3172531155
  • shepherdins.com

Capitol Insurance & Risk Management Group is a Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN. The firm provides personal insurance, commercial insurance, employee benefits, and financial services to individuals and businesses throughout the Indianapolis area and...

Ranked #1 of 13 Insurance Agency listings in IndianapolisScores updated Jun 21, 2026

#3Binford Insurance

4.8 Google rating

Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Binford Insurance website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility43
SEO82
  • Insurance Agency
  • Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 3175883825
  • binfordinsurance.com

Binford Insurance is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN, located at 600 E Carmel Dr #269. The agency provides personal and commercial insurance to families and businesses in Indianapolis and the surrounding area, including Fishers and Carmel. Services...

Ranked #3 of 13 Insurance Agency listings in IndianapolisScores updated Jun 7, 2026

#4Easy Street Insurance

5.0 Google rating

Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Easy Street Insurance website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility43
SEO80
  • Insurance Agency
  • Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 3178829602
  • easystreetins.com

Easy Street Insurance is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN. The agency specializes in helping seniors navigate Medicare coverage, serving clients in Indianapolis, Fishers, and Fort Wayne. Co-founders Jess and Sandra Carrasquillo have assisted thousands...

Ranked #6 of 13 Insurance Agency listings in IndianapolisScores updated Jun 7, 2026

#5McClain Matthews Insurance of Indianapolis

4.9 Google rating

Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
McClain Matthews Insurance of Indianapolis website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility45
SEO81
  • Insurance Agency
  • Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 3172987500
  • mcclainmatthewsinsurance.com

McClain Matthews Insurance of Indianapolis: McClain Matthews Insurance is an insurance agency in Indianapolis, IN. Serving families and businesses throughout Marion County, the agency provides a variety of personal insurance options, including auto, home, and condo coverage. They also specialize in...

Ranked #4 of 13 Insurance Agency listings in IndianapolisScores updated Jun 15, 2026

#6Breneman Insurance Group

5.0 Google rating

Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Breneman Insurance Group website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility44
SEO75
  • Insurance Agency
  • Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 3177862200
  • bpinsured.com

Breneman Insurance Group is an insurance agency in Indianapolis, IN. Serving clients throughout Indiana and Illinois, this independent agency provides a variety of personal and business insurance solutions, including home, auto, RV, motorcycle, and condo...

Ranked #7 of 13 Insurance Agency listings in IndianapolisScores updated Jun 7, 2026

#7Insurance Associates of Indiana

4.7 Google rating · 29 reviews

Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Insurance Associates of Indiana website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility40
SEO71
  • Insurance Agency
  • Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 4632559844
  • insai.biz

Insurance Associates of Indiana is an insurance agency in Indianapolis, IN. The agency helps consumers save money and assists businesses in reducing risk. It offers a comprehensive suite of insurance products covering vehicles, property, and commercial...

Ranked #8 of 13 Insurance Agency listings in IndianapolisScores updated Jun 17, 2026
Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Allstate Insurance Agency: AOG Group website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility34
SEO70
  • Insurance Agency
  • Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 3179812046
  • insuranceagencyindianapolisaog.com

Allstate Insurance Agency: AOG Group is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN, located at 4705 E 96th St Suite 31. Led by Denette Miller and her experienced agents, the agency provides insurance solutions for Indiana families and businesses. Their services...

Ranked #9 of 13 Insurance Agency listings in IndianapolisScores updated Jun 9, 2026
Visit WebsiteView ListingCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
A

Score breakdown

AI Visibility11
SEO43
  • Insurance Agency
  • Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 3174849195
  • driveaffordable.com

Affordable Insurance Agency INC is an insurance agency in Indianapolis, IN. They specialize in providing low-cost auto insurance and services such as SR-50 and SR-22 filings, driver's license reinstatements, and non-owner policies. With over three decades of...

Ranked #12 of 13 Insurance Agency listings in IndianapolisScores updated Jun 9, 2026
Is this your business? Claim your free listing →

BizScoreAI ranks 9 insurance agencies in Indianapolis, Indiana by BizScore, a measured composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, local citations, local search pages and profile completeness. Rankings come from the scores, never from paid placement. Open any profile for its full breakdown, and claim your free listing if it is your business.

Frequently Asked Questions

How are insurance agencies in Indianapolis ranked on BizScoreAI?

By BizScore, a measured composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, local citations, local search pages and profile completeness. No listing pays for position; the formulas are published on the How We Score page.

How many insurance agencies in Indianapolis, Indiana does BizScoreAI track?

9 insurance agencies in Indianapolis currently meet the profile-quality bar for this page, with an average BizScore of 57 and a top score of 69.

What does AI Visibility mean for a insurance agency?

It measures whether AI assistants and AI-powered search can find, read and cite the business's website: structured data, crawlability, clear entity information and content that answers questions. 22% of measured insurance agencies in Indianapolis score 50 or higher.

Is being listed free?

Yes. Every insurance agency in Indianapolis is listed and scored for free, and claiming a listing is free too.