Craig's Cake Shop

Craig's Cake Shop is a bakery in Verona, WI, located at 604 W Verona Ave. Founded in 2000, it is a commercially licensed bakery with a long history of serving the Madison area. The shop specializes in custom cakes and desserts for life milestones, including weddings, birthdays, and anniversaries. Customers can order custom creations with at least one week's notice or stop in daily during business hours for grab-and-go cakes, cupcakes, and push-ups. The bakery holds a rating of 4.70 based on customer reviews.

The team at Craig's Cake Shop hand-bakes and decorates all desserts in Verona, Wisconsin, using time-tested recipes. A key feature of their offerings is the exclusive use of buttercream frosting for all cake designs, ensuring that every slice tastes as good as it looks. This approach allows customers to enjoy a smooth finish without sacrificing flavor. The bakery offers specific product lines such as two-layer mini cakes that serve four to five people, detailed birthday cakes, and wedding cakes. They also provide e-gift cards for those looking to give a sweet present. The business emphasizes that flavor and rich texture are the primary goals, with design serving to enhance the overall experience.

The shop sits on West Verona Avenue, about a quarter of a mile from the UW Health Verona Clinic. It is located roughly three-tenths of a mile from Thompson Park and about half a mile from Art House 360. Harriet Park is also nearby, approximately six-tenths of a mile away.

Craig's Cake Shop is known for its positive customer rating and its two-decade history of baking in the Verona community. The bakery combines dedicated craftsmanship with accessible options for both planned celebrations and spontaneous sweet cravings.

In Verona, Craig's Cake Shop stands out for its commitment to buttercream desserts and its long-standing presence in the local bakery scene.