Wylie Insurance Agency

Wylie Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Wylie, TX, located at 201 Calloway St. This independent agency provides auto, homeowners, business, and benefits insurance to residents and local enterprises. The firm represents its customers rather than specific carriers, offering a choice among A-rated providers such as Travelers, Safeco, State Auto, Kemper, Progressive, and Foremost for property and casualty coverage, and Blue Cross, Aetna, United Healthcare, Humana, and Cigna for life and health needs. The agency holds a 4.80 rating based on customer reviews.

Founded in 1898, Wylie Insurance Agency is the oldest business in Wylie, TX. Its ownership history includes notable local names such as Housewright, Gallagher, and Smith. Current owner John Yeager purchased the agency in 1973 and has maintained its standalone building at 201 Calloway since 1985, following previous locations that included a home-based office, a hardware store, downtown storefront space, and bank offices. As an independent agency, it is not an employee of the insurance companies it represents, allowing it to act solely in the client’s best interest. The office operates Monday through Thursday from 8:30 am to 5:00 pm and on Fridays from 8:30 am to 4:00 pm.

Wylie Insurance Agency combines over a century of local history with the flexibility of independent representation. Its long-standing presence in Wylie, TX, demonstrates a sustained commitment to serving the community’s insurance needs with personalized attention and a wide selection of reputable carriers.

Located on Calloway St, the agency is about a tenth of a mile from South State Highway 78 and South Ballard Avenue. It sits near Olde City Park and the Wylie Acting Group, both approximately two tenths of a mile away.

BizScoreAI assigns Wylie Insurance Agency a Performance score of 87 out of 100, which measures website loading speed to keep visitors engaged and aid search engine ranking. The agency holds a Discoverability score of 75 out of 100.