Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency

Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Pittsburgh, PA, located at 201 S Highland Ave Suite 303. The firm serves individuals, families, and businesses across Pittsburgh and Pennsylvania, with specific reach into Mount Lebanon, McMurray, and Wexford. As an independent multi-line agency, it provides Auto, Home, Life, and Commercial Business Insurance, including specialized products like Professional Liability (Errors and Omissions) coverage for accountants, attorneys, and consultants. The agency holds a 5.00 rating based on customer reviews.

The agency is a leading provider of ERIE Insurance in the region. ERIE Insurance was founded in 1925 by H.O. Hirt and O.G. Crawford with a purpose to provide perfect protection and service at the lowest possible cost. The company’s tagline, “The ERIE is Above all in SERvIcE,” reflects this history. As independent agents, Preston & Grafton leverages relationships with top national and regional carriers to offer comparative quotes and competitive pricing. The staff has spent over a decade building relationships within Pittsburgh communities, aiming to simplify insurance complexities for clients. They offer services ranging from standard home and auto policies to niche commercial protections, such as cyber incident preparedness and claims handling for travelers outside standard territories. The agency maintains locations in Squirrel Hill, Mt. Lebanon, McMurray, and Wexford to provide convenient access to personalized insurance solutions.

The agency’s standing is defined by its perfect 5.00 customer rating, reflecting the trust clients place in its service. As an independent agency with long-term relationships with top national and regional carriers, it provides competitive pricing and expert solutions. The team serves as a trusted advisor, helping clients navigate changing life circumstances and insurance needs with a focus on personalized service and comprehensive protection.

Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency combines its perfect local reputation with the extensive product range of ERIE Insurance to provide reliable protection for Pittsburgh residents and businesses.

The agency sits on South Highland Avenue, near the South Highland Avenue Bridge and Shadyside Plaza. It is also close to the Steel City Improv Theater and Centre Avenue.

BizScoreAI gives the business a Discoverability score of 100 out of 100, which ensures AI crawlers can find every page of the website. A Performance score of 98 out of 100 means the site loads quickly, keeping visitors engaged and helping with search rankings. The agency ranks number 1 of 27 Insurance Agent businesses that BizScoreAI has scored in Pittsburgh.

Services:

• Auto Insurance
• Business Owners Package Insurance
• Group Benefits
• Homeowners Insurance
• Individual Health Insurance