Buttercooky Bakery & Café of Manhasset

Buttercooky Bakery & Café of Manhasset is a Coffee Shop in Manhasset, NY. The bakery serves Long Island residents with fresh‑baked cookies, pastries, French pastries, breads, cupcakes, cake pops, macrons, pies, cheesecakes, and a full range of specialty cakes including wedding, birthday, graduation and religious cakes. Operated by the third‑generation Borgognone family, the shop has been providing baked goods for over a decade in Manhasset and draws on more than 60 years of family baking experience across its three Long Island locations. Customers have given the café a rating of 4.10 stars.

The Manhasset location is part of a family‑owned business that began in 1962 in Floral Park and expanded to three sites. The bakery’s story emphasizes its role as a small, third‑generation operation that has become a fixture in the community, offering a menu that varies slightly by location but consistently includes breakfast pastries, French pastries, cakes, breads, and assorted sweets. The shop highlights its ability to create custom cakes for birthdays, graduations, weddings and religious celebrations, reflecting a long tradition of serving family milestones.

Buttercooky Bakery & Café of Manhasset is situated on Plandome Road at 140 Plandome Rd. It sits just a few metres from the Manhasset Gold Star Memorial and is about a tenth of a mile from Mary Jane Davies Green, the Town of North Hempstead offices, North Hempstead Town Hall, and the former site of Plandome Road School, placing it in the heart of the local civic and recreational area.

With more than six decades of family baking heritage, Buttercooky Bakery & Café brings a trusted, home‑grown bakery experience to the Manhasset coffee scene, offering residents a familiar place for quality pastries and celebratory cakes.