Amica Mutual Insurance Company of Raynham

Amica Mutual Insurance Company of Raynham is an insurance agent in Raynham, MA. As a branch of the oldest mutual insurer of automobiles in the country, the company offers auto, home, marine, personal umbrella liability, and life insurance products. The Raynham location serves residents seeking coverage for their vehicles, properties, and other assets, providing access to both online self-service tools and live representatives for quoting and claims assistance. The business holds a rating of 4.20 based on customer reviews.

The parent organization has operated since 1907, maintaining a focus on long-term financial stability and policyholder ownership. This structure allows the company to prioritize sound advice and recommendations tailored to individual needs over profit-driven metrics. The company is known for its customer service, having earned the top spot in the J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study. This marks its 12th property claims award, making it the most awarded home insurance company for claims satisfaction in that specific study category. The company’s score of 773 on a 1,000-point scale was 71 points higher than the study average. Additional recognitions include a 5 out of 5 star rating from NerdWallet for car insurance and an A+ rating from AM Best. For those who select a dividend policy, the company returns up to 20% of premiums, sharing in its financial success with policyholders. Customer service representatives are available around the clock for claims, while sales and general support operate extended hours, including weekends and late evenings on weekdays.

The Raynham office is located on Paramount Dr, situated about a half-mile from New State Highway. It is approximately 0.6 miles from South School and 1.1 miles from Orchard Street. The site is also within 1.2 miles of the South Street East Bridge and Betty Hill, and about 1.3 miles from the Amvets Highway. These landmarks place the office in a central part of the community, easily accessible from major regional roads and local infrastructure.

The company’s standing as the oldest mutual auto insurer in the country, combined with its consistent recognition for claims satisfaction and financial stability, distinguishes it among insurance providers in the area. Its policyholder-owned model ensures that decisions are made with the long-term interests of customers in mind, rather than external shareholders.

In Raynham, MA, Amica Mutual Insurance Company of Raynham stands out for its century-long history of mutual ownership and its proven track record in delivering high-satisfaction claims service to local policyholders.