The Happy Caterer

The Happy Caterer is a Catering business in Goshen, IN. It provides homestyle Amish‑inspired meals for weddings, family reunions, church functions, school events, small‑business Christmas dinners, corporate gatherings and other occasions. Specializing in meals made from scratch, the company highlights Amish‑style recipes, including its own Amish peanut butter, and serves guests throughout Goshen and the surrounding area. Customers have awarded it a perfect 5.00 rating.

Founded and operated by Joann Schlabach, who grew up in an Amish community, The Happy Caterer draws on family cooking traditions learned from her mother and grandmother. Joann and her husband Dave run a full‑service operation that handles everything from set‑up to clean‑up, allowing hosts to relax while the food is delivered on time and ready to eat. The menu features a wide selection of appetizers such as fruit kabobs, fresh vegetable trays and assorted roll‑ups, as well as entrees that include roast beef, poppy seed chicken, baked pineapple ham, grilled chicken, turkey roast (when available) and a “poor man’s steak.” Side options range from green beans and corn to mixed vegetables and baked beans, while salads include tossed varieties, spinach with strawberries, potato salad, and broccoli‑cauliflower blends. Desserts are offered in cupcakes, pies, chocolate, peanut butter, cherry Dutch apple, pecan, and fresh fruit bowls with glaze. Party packages let clients choose combinations of entrees, potatoes, vegetables, salads, bread, and beverages such as Amish peanut butter, iced tea or lemonade. All meat is sourced locally and the bread comes from a nearby Amish bakery, supporting regional producers while ensuring high quality.

With a focus on wholesome, delicious food and attentive service, The Happy Caterer stands out in Goshen for delivering authentic Amish‑style catering that consistently earns delighted guests and a flawless rating.