Coyles Homemade Ice Cream of Lindenhurst

Coyles Homemade Ice Cream of Lindenhurst is an ice cream shop in Lindenhurst, IL, located at 189 S Wellwood Ave. The shop holds a rating of 4.70 based on customer reviews. The Lindenhurst location is one of several spots run by Coyle's, a family-run operation that started in Bay Shore in 1985 and has spent nearly four decades building a reputation for homemade ice cream made from locally sourced ingredients.

Every flavor is made in-house using time-honored recipes, and the menu covers the full range of ice cream shop fare. Customers can order classic sundaes, signature shakes, and signature cakes alongside a full lineup of homemade novelties crafted fresh on-site. The novelties include Tartufos with black cherries layered between vanilla and chocolate ice cream dipped in Belgian chocolate, Karamel Krisp sandwiches made with vanilla ice cream between caramel Rice Krispy treats, and Coated Cones dipped in Belgian chocolate. For a more nostalgic experience, the Blast from the Past section serves up banana boats, root beer floats, Brooklyn egg creams, and old-fashioned ice cream sodas topped with whipped cream and a cherry. The shop also stocks Coyle's branded merchandise, including the Coyles Cap and the Coyles Signature Tee.

Coyle's has built much of its identity around community involvement. The shop partners with nearby schools and charities and runs events such as the Cops & Cones gathering in Lindenhurst, which drew more than 140 kids for free cones and police vehicle tours. A Student of the Month program with local schools rounds out the community work.

With nearly forty years of continuous operation and a strong customer rating, Coyle's has earned its place as a steady fixture on Long Island's ice cream scene, now serving Lindenhurst from South Wellwood Avenue.