Mixed Fillings Pie Shop

Mixed Fillings Pie Shop is a bakery in Jacksonville, Florida, located at 440 W Adams St. The shop is family-owned and operated, baking scratch-made sweet and savory pies from real ingredients, with crusts handmade using real butter rather than margarine. Its pies have been recognized nationally, including features in Southern Living and Good Morning America, and it was voted the number one pie shop in Florida in 2021 and 2022. Mixed Fillings also hosts hands-on baking classes for beginners and seasoned bakers, along with community gatherings, storytelling and events, and it delivers handmade goods to family gatherings, weddings, catering and special occasions. It holds a rating of 4.90 from customer reviews.

The shop bakes in small batches and sells on Fridays from 10am until sold out, and it sets up at the Riverside Arts Market every Saturday. Its seasonal menu rotates, and its summer class enrollment opens under the name Prep School. Through a program called Pie It Forward Florida, the shop builds community one slice at a time.

The shop sits in Jacksonville's historic Downtown District, about a tenth of a mile from the Duval County Courthouse, the Ed Austin Building and the Office of the State Attorney. West Bay Street and West Forsyth Street are each about a tenth of a mile away, and the Central train station is roughly the same distance.

Mixed Fillings is known for its creativity, warmth and crust, and customers have rated it 4.90. For scratch-made Southern pies, baking classes and community events in downtown Jacksonville, Mixed Fillings Pie Shop is a name locals know.